All-Americans
| First Team
All-American |
||
| 1995 | Emily Stauffer '98-99 | M |
| 1996 | Emily Stauffer '98-99 | M |
| Naomi Miller '99 | F | |
| Second Team
All-American |
||
| 1982 | Alicia Carillo '85 | F |
| Jennifer Greeley '85 | M | |
| 1983 | Kelly Landry '85 | F |
| 1984 | Kelly Landry '85 | F |
| 1987 | Tracee Whitley '88 | G |
| 1998 | Emily Stauffer '98-99 | M |
| Third Team
All-American |
||
| 1984 | Tracee Whitley '88 | G |
| 1985 | Tracee Whitley '88 | G |
| 1996 | Ann Browning '00 | G |
| Karen Gudeman '98 | F | |
| Devon Bingham '99 | M | |
| 2001 | Katie Westfall '04 | M |
| 2004 | Liza Barber '05 | B |
| Honorable Mention
All-American |
||
| 1980 | Cat Ferrante '82 | F |
| Kelly Gately '83 | M | |
| 1981 | Debi Field '85 | B |
| 1994 | Emily Stauffer '98-9 | M |
