All-Time Captains
| 1923 | Elliott Perkins ’23 |
| 1924 | Kimball Prince |
| 1925 | Dudley Merrill ’26 |
| 1926 | Dudley Merrill ’26 |
| 1927 | T. C. Sturtevant ’27 |
| 1928 | W. I. Gregg ’28 |
| 1929 | Frederick E. Farnsworth ’29 |
| 1930 | Horace N. Roberts ’30 |
| 1931 | Harper Woodward ’31 |
| 1932 | R. R. White ’32 |
| 1933 | G. F. F. Lombard ’33 |
| 1934 | Freeman F. Jones ’34 |
| 1935 | T. H. P. Whitney ’35 |
| 1936 | John W. Perry ’36 |
| 1937 | Mark H. Dall ’37 |
| 1938 | George von L. Meyer III ’38 |
| 1939 | Vincent R. Bailey ’40 |
| 1940 | Vincent R. Bailey ’40 |
| 1941 | Seth C. Crocker ’41 |
| 1942 | Albert L. Lincoln, Jr. ’42 |
| 1943 | Richard W. Swanson ’43 |
| 1946 | Howland P. Hall ’48 |
| 1947 | Howland P. Hall ’48 |
| 1948 | Arthur P. Hall ’47 ocC |
| 1949 | David C. Clark ’49 |
| 1950 | William J. Chadwick ’51 |
| 1951 | William J. Chadwick ’51 |
| 1952 | Theodore G. House ’52 |
| 1953 | Richard K. Lincoln ’53 |
| 1954 | Oliver S. Leland, Jr. ’54 |
| 1955 | William G. Coughlin ’55 |
| 1956 | Richard L. Timpson ’57 |
| 1957 | Richard L. Timpson ’57 |
| 1958 | Viggo C. Bertelsen, Jr. ’58 |
| 1959 | Mark Hoffman, Jr. ’59 |
| 1960 | Michael W. Christian ’60 |
| 1961 | David K. Richards ’61 |
| 1962 | James V. Miller Jr. ’63 |
| 1963 | Robert M. Russell ’63 |
| 1964 | James R. MacMahon ’64 |
| 1965 | Galen Brewster ’65 |
| 1966 | Jonathan A. Eddy ’66 |
| 1967 | Gilbert T. Vincent ’67 |
| 1968 | Brian D. Sullivan ’68 |
| 1969 | Robert L. Wolff, Jr. ’69 |
| 1970 | David B. Harman ’71 |
| 1971 | David B. Harman ’71 |
| 1972 | Howard D. Burnett ’72 |
| 1973 | Andrew S. Narva ’73 |
| 1974 | Lewis C. Ross ’74 |
| 1975 | Edward Reynolds III ’76 |
| 1976 | Edward Reynolds III ’76 |
| 1977 | Jeffrey B. Parker ’77 |
| 1978 | John Pickering II ’78 |
| 1979 | Jeffrey W. Cooley ’79 |
| 1980 | Kevin E. Gaut ’80 |
| 1981 | Jeffrey T. MacMillan ’81 |
| 1982 | Ethan D. Goldings ’82 |
| 1983 | Jess I. Park ’83-84 |
| 1984 | Harold E Fleming ’84 |
| William J. Patterson ’84 | |
| 1985 | Paul D. Natterson ’85 |
| 1986 | Alan A. “Trip” Switzer ’86 |
| 1987 | Michael T. Horvath ’88 |
| 1988 | James A. Himes ’88 |
| 1989 | Eric L. Davis ’89 |
| 1990 | James M. Baker ’90 |
| 1991 | Andrew M. Cameron ’91 |
| William M. Dixon III ’91 | |
| 1992 | Thomas D. Caughey ’92 |
| James G. Goettsch ’92 | |
| 1993 | William C. Braun ’93 |
| 1994 | John B. Roberts ’94 |
| 1995 | Christopher J. Schulte ’95 |
| 1996 | Matthew B. Emans ’96 |
| Ogilvie A. F. Wilson ’96 | |
| 1997 | Edward A. Shergalis III ’97 |
| Ryan S. Wise ’97 | |
| 1998 | Jonathan D. Kibera ’98 |
| Christopher J. Sims ’98 | |
| 1999 | Thomas M. Fallows ’99 |
| David M. Weiss ’99 | |
| 2000 | Angus R. Maclaurin ’00 |
| Sujit M. Raman ’99-00 | |
| 2001 | Jesse R. Elzinga ’01 |
| Richard A. McCormack ’00-01 | |
| 2002 | Joseph D. Finelli ’02 |
| Patrick D. Todd ’02 | |
| 2003 | Nicholas P. Blannin ’03 |
| 2004 | Chris Mercaldi |
| 2005 | Patrick J. Haas ’05 |
| 2006 | Daniel A. Reid ’06 |
| 2007 | Nicholas S. Downing ’07 |
| 2008 | Patrick J. Mulcahy ’08 |
| 2009 | Jeffrey D. Overington ’09 |
| 2010 | Martin Eiermann '10 |
| 2011 | William C. Newell '11 |
| 2012 | Thomas W. Nesel '12 |
| 2013 | Erich Schultze '13 |
| Matthew O'Leary '13 |
